Exploring the Best Restaurants in the Florida Keys

Foodies will find heaven on the Florida Keys, a chain of tropical islands located roughly 120 miles off the southern coast of Florida. Known for its stunning views of the ocean, lively atmosphere, and distinctive food scene, the Keys provide an amazing eating experience. These are the top five eateries in the Florida Keys that each traveler ought to be aware of.
An idyllic island off Florida’s southern coast, the Florida Keys provide a gastronomic paradise where the sea’s flavors harmoniously meld with the lively local way of life. These best restaurants in the Florida Keys are sure to treat you to a lovely culinary journey.

1. Restaurants in the Florida Keys: Latitudes

Latitudes, a restaurant on Sunset Key, provides a unique eating experience. Only reachable via private ferry from Key West, this elegant eatery embodies the pinnacle of elegance and romance.

Picture yourself having dinner beneath swaying palm trees while the soft sounds of the ocean play in the background.

Inspired by the flavors of the Caribbean, the menu offers delectable meals including fresh Key West prawns, exquisite fillet mignon, and luscious lobster soup. The food may be a bit pricey, but enjoying a sunset view while eating is one of the best things you can do for yourself when you visit the city.

Perfect service, breathtaking sunset views, and a magical evening make every meal here count. Book your reservations early.

Address: 245 Front St, Key West, FL 33040, United States

Phone: +1 305-292-5394

2. Blue Heaven

Blue Heaven is a must-see for a taste of the unique charm that is Key West. This eccentric location, well-known for its relaxed atmosphere with roosters running amok in the courtyard, provides a distinctive dinner encounter.

Local favorites like French toast with banana bread for breakfast and freshly caught fish for the evening are featured on the menu. Key West’s creative energy is captured in Blue Heaven’s laid-back vibe, live music, and colorful artwork.

It’s the ideal location to relax and savor the authentic flavor of the island. According to a diner, the place is heaven on a plate. Count on them for your breakfast and lunch and you will not be disappointed.

Address: 729 Thomas St, Key West, FL 33040, United States

Phone: +1 305-296-8666

3. Louie’s Backyard

One of Key West’s gastronomic treasures is Louie’s Backyard. It provides elegant dining al fresco. For more than 40 years, this classy restaurant by the sea has been a mainstay in the neighborhood.

Louie’s Backyard is well-known for its inventive, modern American cooking. Dishes like grilled swordfish, conch fritters, and rich desserts are made with the freshest ingredients available.

With a deck facing the Atlantic Ocean, the gorgeous setting makes it an excellent ideal location for a memorable event or a romantic evening. Secure yourself a good spot and let the deliciousness of the meal hit the spot.

Address: 700 Waddell Ave, Key West, FL 33040, United States

Phone: +1 305-294-1061

4. Hogfish Bar & Grill

Hogfish Bar & Grill is a hidden gem that is conveniently located in Key West, right in the middle of Stock Island. This beloved neighborhood spot is well-known for both its hogfish sandwich and its laid-back, welcoming ambiance.

The restaurant’s riverfront setting enhances the relaxed, Old Florida charm with breathtaking views of the marina. Fresh seafood, chilled beer and live music are just a few of the things that make Hogfish Bar & Grill a real Keys experience that draws people in.

You can’t go wrong with the blackened tuna and hogfish tacos. Also, expect the place to be crowded during the peak hours. Everyone wants something great for their taste buds.

Address: 6810 Front St, Stock Island, FL 33040, United States

Phone: +1 305-293-4041

Here are some travel insurance options you need

5. Marker 88

Since 1967, Marker 88 in Islamorada has been providing services to both residents and visitors.

It is well-known for its restaurants on the beach and breathtaking sunsets. Additionally, this renowned eatery serves a menu that honors flavors found in the Keys.

With delectable cuisine served in a laid-back, tropical setting, Marker 88 serves everything from coconut shrimp to fresh stone crab claws and key lime pie. It also serves freshly caught hogfish and the well-known lobster mac & cheese. Every visit to the restaurant is certain to be unforgettable because of its dedication to quality and hospitality.

Enjoying a dinner at Marker 88 is an authentic Florida Keys experience.

Address: 88000 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada, FL 33036, United States

Phone: +1 305-852-9315

 6. The Fish House

The Fish House in Key Largo is a must-visit for those looking for the freshest seafood in a laid-back, nautical setting. The restaurant takes great satisfaction in serving well-cooked fish that is fished nearby.

Among the restaurant’s signature dishes is the renowned Matecumbe-style fish, which is baked with tomatoes, shallots, fresh basil, capers, olive oil, and a squeeze of lemon. The Fish House is a must-visit for seafood enthusiasts as it provides a taste of real Keys cuisine.

Ask for their sauteed mahi mahi dish, which comes with fries, and end your meal with their key lime pie. You will want to visit again, believe me.

 Address: 102401 Overseas Hwy, Key Largo, FL 33037, United States

Phone: +1 305-451-4665

If you are a first-time traveler, you need this information

7. Seven Fish

Nestled in the heart of Key West, Seven Fish is a small, casual eatery renowned for its creative and fresh fish offerings. The warm atmosphere and menu, which includes standout dishes like pan-seared local fish and the well-liked tuna meatballs, combine to offer a special and inviting dining experience.

For over 20 years, this fantastic spot has been a hallmark in the city. Everything is made from scratch and you don’t want to miss your favorite fish dish. Their house specialty remains Thai Curry Snapper.

They also have 7 Fish Meatloaf and Banana chicken, which have been the locals’ favorites. Send your choice down with a glass of wine or a specialty drink. Ensure to save room for any of their homemade desserts.

While enjoying the best of Key West’s seafood selections, each guest is made to feel at home by the informed and welcoming staff. There is something about this spot that would make you return.

 Address: 921 Truman Ave, Key West, FL 33040, United States

Phone: +1 305-296-2777

See how you can get the most of your travel here

8. Square Grouper Bar and Grill

The Square Grouper Bar and Grill, which is situated on Cudjoe Key, is well-known for its inventive food and lively ambiance. The eatery provides a wide selection of food, offering meals that appeal to both seafood lovers and those looking for something different, like the delicious prawns and grits and the substantial tuna nachos.

Their House Smoked Fish Dip is a must-try. But if you want something else, a plate of Conch Chowder, Island Shrimp Cakes with Banana Pepper Aioli, BBQ Bacon Wrapped Jumbo Shrimp, Warm Mexican Street Corn Dip, or Key Lime Pie will hit the spot. There are salads and small plates to pair with your meal.

Offering a genuine flavor of island life, The Square Grouper is a favorite among both locals and tourists due to its rustic decor and laid-back feel. They are open Tuesday through Saturday for your lunch and dinner.

 Address: 22658 Overseas Hwy, Cudjoe Key, FL 33042, United States

 Phone: +1 305-745-8880

9. Little Palm Island Resort & Spa – Dining Room

In the Florida Keys, the Dining Room at Little Palm Island Resort & Spa is the height of opulence. This remote sanctuary, only reachable by boat or aircraft, provides a unique and romantic dining experience.

The menu offers delectable options like the herb-crusted rack of lamb and the grilled lobster tail, both of which draw inspiration from French and Caribbean cuisine. Enjoying a meal here is a sensory delight, complete with flawless service and breathtaking views enhancing every moment.

Address: 28500 Overseas Hwy, Little Torch Key, FL 33042, United States

 Phone: +1 305-684-8341

Check out how you can save for your upcoming trip

10. A&B Lobster House

Perched on the historic Key West Bight Marina, A&B Lobster House has been serving up seafood delicacies since 1947. It has elegant old-world charm and specializes in fresh lobster, prime steaks, and an extensive wine list.

This is a place to enjoy the freshest seafood on the island. The meals are fused with classic and modern-style cooking. Enjoy your meal with a glass of cocktail. Bring your significant other and treat them to a sumptuous evening meal.

The rich mahogany bar and waterfront views create an inviting atmosphere. Signature dishes like the baked stuffed lobster and the surf and turf platter highlight the best of land and sea.

Address: 700 Front St, Key West, FL 33040, United States

Phone: +1 305-294-5880

Read also: Restaurants in Los Angeles

11. Pierre’s Restaurant

Located in Islamorada, Pierre’s Restaurant is a two-story, plantation-style house. It brings a sophisticated dining experience to your doorstep. The owners nestled it on a private beach and the menu comprises a fusion of French and World cuisine.

It has dishes like the tender veal chop and the flavorful seafood paella. The elegant interior pairs beautifully with the stunning sunset views over Florida Bay. It is designed with antique decor and candlelit tables. Thus, it becomes a romantic destination for dinner with loved ones.

Address: 81600 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada, FL 33036, United States

Phone: +1 305-664-3225

12. El Siboney Restaurant

For an authentic taste of Cuban cuisine in Key West, El Siboney Restaurant is the place to go. This family-owned eatery offers hearty portions of traditional dishes like ropa vieja, lechón asado, and picadillo.

The unassuming, cozy atmosphere and affordable prices make it a favorite among locals and visitors. Don’t miss the house-made sangria and the flan for a sweet ending to your meal.

Alternatively, order the steak (skirt) and shrimp or a Delmonico steak. Everything is cooked perfectly. Pair it with salad and sweet tostones. You will likely visit again after the first encounter.

El Siboney’s warm hospitality and flavorful dishes ensure a memorable dining experience. Please, note that the place is off the beaten path and you may need a map.

 Address: 900 Catherine St, Key West, FL 33040, United States

 Phone: +1 305-296-4184

You may also like: How to satisfy your wanderlust

13. Mangrove Mama’s

Mangrove Mama’s, located on Sugarloaf Key, is a beloved spot for locals and tourists. This laid-back restaurant is housed in a charming, rustic building. Expect to relish delicious seafood and island-inspired dishes.

Favorites include the conch fritters, blackened grouper sandwiches, and key lime pie. Try their delicious Blackened Yellow Tail Snapper sandwich and you will be glad you did. There are other excellent choices.

The outdoor seating under the shady mangroves creates a relaxed and enjoyable dining experience, capturing the essence of the Keys’ casual lifestyle. In the evening, they play live music. Their service is also captivating and friendly. It is a very sweet spot.

 Address: 19991 Overseas Hwy, Summerland Key, FL 33042, United States

Phone: +1 305-745-3030

14. The Flaming Buoy Filet Co.

Situated in a cozy bungalow in Key West, The Flaming Buoy Filet Co. offers an eclectic menu with a mix of Caribbean, American, and seafood dishes. The spot boasts a welcoming atmosphere and creative cuisine. Some of their standout dishes are the bacon-wrapped scallops, lobster mac and cheese, and the flavorful fresh catch of the day.

The intimate setting combines attentive service and innovative dishes. This makes The Flaming Buoy Filet Co. a unique dining destination in the Florida Keys.

Address: 424 Eaton St, Key West, FL 33040, United States

Phone: +1 305-295-7970

Conclusion

Each of the restaurants in the Florida Keys provides more than just a meal—they provide a glimpse into the island’s soul, showcasing the best in local cuisine, culture, and hospitality. Whether you seek an elegant evening out or a laid-back lunch by the water, these top restaurants will leave you with unforgettable memories and a deeper appreciation for this unique region.